inaccurate # of comments unrelated to SK2

are you using the beta version of sk2?
https://wp-plugins.net/sk2/
you need 2.1 beta

But even when Spam Karma is disabled there’s still a problem..

hmm.. Your comment form looks broken.
Well, I recommend trying to install the beta version above, and then running all your approved comments through the compatibility plugin. I’ve heard this works well for correcting this problem.

I’m experiencing the same problem after importing from LiveJournal, without using SK2.

I have over 600 comments — SK2 admin only allows for me to select the most recent 30… how can I select more? :-/

I was able to run SK2 on the first 30 and it fixed the comment counts for their posts. But I see no way to select the others.

I just read on Dr. Dave’s spam karma site that the 2.1 beta version incorporates the fix.
https://unknowngenius.com/blog/wordpress/spam-karma/
May wanna try that?

I have already downloaded the Beta 2.1 of SK…. it doesn’t do anything for me. I repeat, my problem is <b>NOT</b> related to Spam Karma.

Well, now it works. All I did was re-upload Spam Karma 2.1 Beta and now it works for some odd reason..

Yeah, I think Dr. Dave updated the beta version yesterday or the day before…
Glad to hear it works!