Hi Erica,
Thanks for getting in touch about this.
It looks like there is a conflict with the theme or one of the installed plugins. Our plugin asks WordPress, “what page is this?” and it’s always saying the Blog page. For WordPress to report the wrong page, there must be a bug in the theme or another plugin that is modifying the result WordPress returns.
I would recommend deactivating all other plugins on the site and check if that resolves the issue. If this works, you can re-activate each of your plugins until the issue returns to find out which one is the culprit. If this doesn’t help, I would recommend activating a different theme temporarily to see if that resolves the issue. If your host lets you create a staging site, you can do this on a staging copy of the site to prevent any disruption for your regular visitors.
Please let me know if this helps, and I will be happy to assist further if needed.