Hi @nickchomey , I don’t think I have any great answers for you at the moment. I set up my dev site with BuddyBoss plugin and the BuddyBoss theme so it looks just like your site, and it’s working perfectly fine for me. So, all I can do is to try and identify any differences between your setup and mine.
Here are some screenshots of my dev site.
Forum with Topics: https://imgur.com/a/1voyU8c
Topic with Replies: https://imgur.com/a/QkiIfwR
Some observations:
– Your forum seems to be nested inside a group, and if I click on the Forums link on your site, there are no forums there. I’m not too familiar with BuddyBoss, so I’m not sure how that works technically, but it might be worth some troubleshooting to create a forum that’s not in a group, submit a topic in that, and see if it works there. If that’s the case, then there might be some extra hooks I need to include in my plugin.
– I also noticed that either you are not displaying the original topic’s post at the top, or you’re confused and treating it as if it was the first reply. If you see my screenshot, the original topic post was titled “Test Topic” and the content of that was “This is a test”. bbPress shows the content of the topic at the top of the replies.
– If there was confusion as I described in that previous point, then that would also explain why you though that sorting replies by voting score was also not working… because that top post is not a reply and should always be at the top because it’s the topic post.