Your link does not have the mpopup class applied to it. If you view the page source the menu item looks like:
<li id="menu-item-3028" class="menu-item menu-item-type-custom menu-item-object-custom"><a href="https://noize.fm/popup.html"><i class="mpopup"></i>Popup</a></li>
The mpopup class is applied to an ‘i’ element within the menu item instead of the menu item. This may be due to your theme or another plugin diddling with the menu walker. To investigate whether this is the case this you can temporarily deactivate all other plugins and switch to a default theme such as twentyfifteen.