Help with paginating posts on site

Hi there, I have a bit of an issue with a site I’m building. I have the front page working, but if I try to go to the second page of posts, it redisplays the “Featured Post” section incorrectly (when it shouldn’t even be displaying it) and it still has the most recent posts on the second page. Can anybody help me out?

Here’s the front page. The second page. And the pastebin for front-page.php.