Gutenberg and Autosave

It shouldn’t be causing a “lag” because it happens in the background, through the REST API.

Do you see any error messages in the Javascript console?

Hello,

I’m facing this issue as well

Console shows:

…wp-json/wp/v2/posts/4786/autosaves
[HTTP/1.0 403 Forbidden 480ms]

– it is online server,
– no other plugins activated
– not possible to create/publish new post or edit old one
– plugins version: 3.5.0

Dannci

Okay, so, you need to figure out why your server is returning a 403 for the REST calls.

Do you have a security plugin blocking the REST API?

Hi,

– it is online server from well-known hosting company . no special server setup.
– no other plugins are used
– it is fresh WordPress installation
– default 2017 theme

And it is issue with whole save/publish functionality (not just autosave).

Thanks

• This reply was modified 6 years, 6 months ago by dannci.

Anything that blocks the REST API calls will cause various issues, because that’s how the editor talks to your site.

The new editor interface is very Javascript oriented. Everything you edit happens in the browser, and then it talks back to the site using the REST API to save things, make changes, etc. It also uses that to get information from the site, like what categories are available and so forth.

So, anything that blocks that wp-json call will essentially break the editor. You need to look at your server configuration and find out what is blocking that call. You may need to ask your host why it’s returning 403 Forbidden messages.

I have a problem with autosave as well.
It freezes and locks up, then I need to reload the entire editing window.
I also get a failed save message on the autosave, even though there’s no problem saving when I manually press the “Save” button.
This feature is really annoying and wastes a lot of time.

Hello christosharrison,

Autosave is a handy feature, but not just for saving, because it (hopefully) maintains contact with the server periodically, so will lower the chance of connection timeout – which if the contents are not saved locally, or you move away from the page before you’ve attempted to save to a text file (copy and paste), then you might not be so happy about having a timeout (which may be similar in effect as to what yourexpireddomains has described – but worse).
Yes though, to the experience that you are having. Clearly the designers have not intended for you to be having this happen. And it may be a combination of a number of factors which are not isolated to Gutenberg, though Gutenberg would probably be involved.
The suggestion you make of being able to turn off the autosave sounds interesting, and would be interesting to see how that progresses.

Hello dannci,
There are some other causes that could be worth checking.
The ones commonly mentioned as standard checks on the net are ;
a) the “.htaccess file”, and
b) file and folder permissions
Samuel Wood is correct when he says that “anything that blocks the REST API calls” will cause issues, and he asked if you have a security plugin.
The problem may be due to security functions that are not just in a plugin.
Less easy to find are other causes and respective solutions, include such things as ;
c) having a CDN
d) having a firewall (in WP, on server, in hosting service, Isp or networking service, in-house)
e) small chance of settings in browser (but not likely)
f) caching systems (within WP, within PHP, on server, on-route through the network & internet, and browser – these are not so much a cause of 403 errors, but having received a 403 error, if one tries to refresh the 403 error page, then in some cases, the browser will refresh the 403 page (which is not likely to change) rather than re-attempt to load the page that caused to 403 page.
Also, having received a 403 message, it is handy to refresh your browser to flush the browser cache – not that that has a big chance of fixing it, but it is quite easy to do to at least eliminate that possibility.

Help for all of those situations is available on the internet, so need not be described here.
But the above should serve as a check list for searching for possible causes.

Hello yourexpireddomains,
Sorry to hear that you find this feature to be really annoying and that it wastes a lot of time. I am not a developer of this plugin, but it might be handy to run your browser in some sort of debug mode to pick up the scenario that the event happens in. The developers however may be able to see if there is a difference in the code for the auto-save save, and save when done manually.
In the mean time, you may be able to find a ‘work around’ for this, to avoid it happening, perhaps by timing the auto-save interval, and then do a manual save before the auto-save gets to activate.
I don’t know the code, but if it has been designed for future flexibility (which is very likely), then there may already be some setting that controls this, but has not been made available in the present user interface. If there is, then it would probably involve doing something like, use the server file manager (or ftp program), and find some php file, look for something like “autosave=true” and change it to “autosave=false”, or “autosave-interval=300″(secs) and change it to “autosave-interval=0” (never).
It might be imagined that you too would like to have christosharrison’s option to disable auto-save. After all, this is a beta test, and until things are known to work with high reliability, then it is helpful to be able to turn-off any function which is not of critical need, in the event that it causes problems under any scenario for any user. That way they can continue testing, without risk of further adverse results – possibly finding more problems, all of which can be reported earlier, and so speed up the development cycle.

And of course, many thanks to all the support crew who are handling these reports, and aiding the rapid development.

I hope this is of some assistance to at least one of you.

This thing is so annoying. It’s autosaving much too often, and I have to sit there and wait for it to complete before I do anything, because for some reason, the changes aren’t being kept.

Tags especially are a problem. When I put in a tag and press the comma, it disappears, then after a few seconds, it reappears.

With autosave now, sometimes it will save entering tags, and I have to keep putting the tags in over and over.

Another example? When autosave happens as you’re publishing and you have to sit there and wait for both to complete? I’ll publish, and then have to sit through an autosave.

And if I try to navigate away, I’ll get that prompt asking me if I’m sure. And so that I don’t fill up my database with auto draft entries, I have to update then navigate away.

This is a problem.

Please give us the option to either disable this, or at least decrease how often it autosaves. I understand what you’re saying about server connection, but there has got to be another way for that to happen in the background.

As it is now, it adds much more time than is necessary to post a blog post.

• This reply was modified 6 years, 6 months ago by Dexter Nelson.

WP 5.0 BREAKS my Autosave Setting!
I have it set to something like 24 hours, because I find it so annoying.
And I Always save when I’m ready to save.

Sure, it’s not causing freezes like others are reporting. But it’s saving drafts like EVERY FEW SECONDS.

Also, Yes, AutoSave seems to interfere with Saving.

I DO seem to be experiencing oddities on post Previews, and Post Updates. Like stuff doesn’t always appear. Or maybe something appears after a delay? I can’t figure it out. But something is not consistent. It’s very confusing. I cannot trust Previews, or Edit saves. Or information in plugin boxes on Edit pages.

I have not had a WP update Break my site in so long, that I no longer go into major stress at update time. To be fair, this did Not break my front end ??
BUT several things on my backend. Mostly stuff on Edit Pages.

If, as you say, it’s some server blocking script thing,
WP 5.0 STILL BROKE a setup that has been functioning Perfectly, As I Want it To for Years.

Most people don’t know how to check and change whatever server setting your are talking about. Or how to figure out how to change whatever useful plugin they are using. And maybe that means find an entirely new plugin that does the Same thing, but without causing this New Issue. UGH. and not likely.

Can you please give a good idea on how to go about learning how I must fix this blocking thing. I realize specifics may depend on my server, or wordpress settup/plugins installed. But in general terms, what am I looking for, and generally what’s a likely scenario for addressing it.

Thank You.

And YES I NEED a Working Option to Reduce or Remove AutoSave !!!!
At the MINIMUM let me delay 5 minutes. Or 1 hour.

PS
Unrelated, but So Annoyed at this Gutenberg thing (that I SOOOO wanted and expected to love), that I HAVE to write a Couple Comments.

PLEASE don’t make “Code View” 2 clicks away!
When in code view you let us easily switch back. You DON’T have an easy link to Get To Code View (which is what I use Most Often!). Instead you have Blank Space, occupying that same area. How about a Button: Code View | Visual View, like you had before! PLEASE ! I’m switching back to classic for this reason alone, after 3 annoying days of giving this one a shot.
Also: 3 SCROLL BARS ?? Two was bad enough. Three is Ridiculous! With plugins, Page Editing has many fields and uses besides jsut typing a new blog post.

• This reply was modified 6 years, 2 months ago by SherylHohman. Reason: I implied that don't experience weird editing errors. Not true. I just don't Understand What these other Edit Page Errors are. Maybe it is "blocking" as they stated. Or maybe it's something else causing inconsistency. I dunno. I just cannot trust Preview or Save or plugin info on Edit pages after a save

OMG! as follow up. I turned ON Classic Editor.
Whew!!
Like is Calm again.
Editing as FAST again. Pleasant.
Preview Works again.
Preview is FAST again.
Preview button automatically switches to the Preview tab again.
Plugins on Edit pages Work again.
Autosave no longer interferes!
Autosave honors my autosave config setting again.
Page is no longer cluttered. Wow. I did not realize HOW intrusive Gutenberg interface was.
Everything is so much EASIER, FASTER.. and Works Better (ie works) with Gutenberg turned OFF.
Thank goodness, there IS such an easy fix. Why did I not do this DAYS ago? Well, I so much Like the Idea of JS, React, Gutenberg.
It’s just not ready for prime time.
Also, the idea of new interface is far greater than the execution and design of it.
Gutenberg takes up SOOO much room on the screen.
And requires too many clicks.
And leaves too much out of the visible view.

And of course causes so many issues.

THANK YOU for including the Classic Plugin !!

Aaah. Happy now. Amazing how much stress and frustration accumulated over this.
The relief is dramatic ??

How do I switch back to classic mode, and can I do it when I’ve already started a post? Now that Gutenberg has been forced on us, I just spent an hour adding and formatting my first blog–a process that usually takes me about 15 minutes, and it is indeed now stuck in “saving” mode, so I can’t publish it.

Forget it. I Opened “Preview” in a new tab, went to the bottom of the post preview, clicked “edit,” which brought me back to the dashboard in NOT stuck in autosave mode, and clicked on publish from there and it’s now posted. Meanwhile, my original working version page is still stuck in autosave mode. So is this going to be the way I have to work around this issue every time I post something?

To switch back to classic mode, you need to install and activate the Classic Editor plugin.
I also like it more than Gutenberg. I don’t even see a feature in Gutenberg that would show how many words long my posts are, which is an important metric.

On the subject of autosave, it would be helpful to have an option to set it manually to turn it on, off or 5 minutes, etc. Lacking that feature you can do this easily. Just add following line to your wp-config.php file:

define(‘AUTOSAVE_INTERVAL’, 86400);

86400 is a full day, so you may want to set it to a smaller number.

Same here, autosave is freezing, had to reload the browser and the post is draft but without anything like text images etc.

This is another users 4 month old topic you are all reviving, which is causing notifications to fly out which may feel spammy.

If you are looking for support, please open your own topics.