Google results suddenly say ‘You Are Banned”

Hello,

We have been using wp-ban to block bad referrer spam etc. and it has been working for us, but suddenly the client noticed this week that when he does a google search for “montebello home care beaumont tx” The hit that comes back says “You Are Banned” via the wp-ban plugin.

Disabling the plugin and resubmitting the URL via search console got the google result to return to normal, but enabling it causes the problem again. I checked the settings and there is nothing new in the list of banned servers (just the usual semalt, etc)

Here’s a screenshot of what the google result looks like with the plugin active:

https://ibb.co/mK2tXH

We’d like to keep using Wp-Ban, as up until now it has been working fine, but i’ve had to disable it for the time being. The site’s WP core and all plugins including wp-ban are and have been kept up-to-date.

Thanks!

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]