Geotagging posts on a single map?

I’ve looked and looked and I can’t find anything (except Big Blog Map which no longer works) that allows me to write a posts, add the address to the post and have a page with a dedicated map showing where all the posts were made. Can anyone recommend one? I’ve been at this for many hours.

We are launching a Dive Bar review site and traveling across country and this would be a great way for end users to pick their location and find the bars we’ve reviewed near them.

I swear I’ve done a fair amount of research and didn’t just jump in here requesting stuff. I’ve found a ton of “add a map to your post” plugins but that won’t work for us. We need a map displaying all the places, across the country we have reviewed.

Thanks in advance!
Jeff
divebartender.com