From Email field not working

Firstly, great plugin as saved me a lot of hassle with hosting provider not sending php mail… However, despite adding in a noreply@ email into the “From Email” field, I still receive the email at my primary Gmail address. This create a problem as then Gmail treats the contact form inbox email the same as the sent email as the addresses are the same. I need to set a different “From Email” so that it looks like it’s not from me. I am using Gmail with SSL encryption and SMTP authentication. Any ideas? Thanks!