For anyone using a redirect in .htaccess to login, simply rename the WP SuperCache plugin, and that should deactivate it, allowing for a login.
For anyone else who wants to deactivate WP SuperCache, do so from the Plugins setting, then delete the Plugin. Alternatives I’ve used with success include ZenCache (free and Pro version), WP Fastest Cache, W3 Total Cache, and HyperCache.
What I like about WP Super Cache is that it’s an Automatic (WordPress) plugin, and creates complete static files which are served well with Apache or NGINX. It’s all magic in .htaccess, and, until this recent update, has worked well. The 1.4.3 update broke a lot of functionality– Preview, login, search, etc.