Emails say IP's blocked, but not the list of blocked IP's

Hi dnharrow,
Unless you blocked these IPs permanently, they will be unblocked after a time set in (Wordfence > Options) which is 5 minutes by default.

Please check the time you set for these options:
– (Wordfence > Options => Rate Limiting Rules => How long is an IP address blocked when it breaks a rule)
– (Wordfence > Options => Login Security Options => Amount of time a user is locked out)

The time set there is a possible reason why you aren’t seeing these IPs there.

Keep me updated,
Thanks.