Doesn’t work with manual orders

Plugin does not seem to work when creating manual orders with Woocommerce. I create an order, add items, fill in both billing/shipping details, and email invoice to customer. However, they get a link to pay and the plugin blocks payment options. (even when all conditions are met to allow payment options).

Basic functionality is working as intended. I set it up to include certain products. These products default to free shipping. Actions: disable payment method.