Does anyone know why my archives aren't working!?

Did you mean .com in above (not .co)?

Have you added index.php to your Permalink setting? The normal archives date format would be

https://www.paveyourlife.com/2012/05/ (which does not work)

nope it’s actually hosted at .co

it was added but I made sure this time by switching it to index.php/2012/09/sample-post/ (which includes the month and the name)

Still nothing. Thank you though, any other ideas?

I am having the exact same problem! Did you ever figure out how to fix it?

Hi there,

I found out that it may be a problem with the theme that I am using.

I am using a lifestyle child theme, by studiopress, and so I have to consult their support forums to find the proper help.

Maybe it’s your theme?

Best,
John