Display list of properties using multiple attributes

We have an attribute for property “status.” The status options are Active, Under Contract, Sold, Price Reduced, New Listing. We want only Active, New Listing, and Price Reduced to show for this particular page (Sold and Under Contract would be on a different page).

[property_overview sorter=on sort_by=post_date per_page=20 status=new listing,active,price reduced]

This is the shortcode I am trying to use. I tried with dashes between the words (e.g. new-listing), underscores (e.g. new_listing), I tried status=’new listing’,’active,’price reduced’; I tried case sensitive. No luck with any of these. Some show one of the statuses, some don’t narrow it down and show everything including Sold and Under Contract. Is there a way to do this?