Customized form results

I need to build a form for a customer that will be a fairly long college football nomination form for the Wuerffel Trophy (similar to the Heisman trophy). They want colleges to fill out the form online and click a submit button and have the results go to 3 different email addresses. I can build the form and setup the results to go to the 3 emails, however, they absolutely require that the form results received in email MUST match the layout/design of their paper copy of the nomination form. Here is a link to a PDF that I made showing an actual email received to show how the email should look with the form results: https://wuerffeltrophy.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/wuerffel-email.pdf.
We’ve been using formexperts.com for years but found that lately the form software is out of date and they are not going to update it. I have to find a different option. It is more important for the form results to match the application form than the actual online form to match it.
Thank you!