Custom login page does not appear

Hello. I entered my website above but please note that I have a coming soon landing page up for now. I would be more than happy to take it down to troubleshoot if necessary.

Here is my issue. I’m currently using PeepSo plugin for social media features on my site. (i’m not sure if this is causing the issue or not) I have set up my custom login page per the instructions. However when I view my site when logged out (and coming soon page turned off of course) instead of seeing the custom login page I see my sites home page in a logged out state. Is there a setting somewhere where I can fix this? I’m probably missing something super simple. Also a secondary question – I love that this provides the registration and lost password links, however will these links automatically be set to use my peepso registration and lost password pages? Thanks in advance for your help! I’m really loving how simple this plugin is to configure and how you can fully customize everything!

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]