Hello @softwaregeek
I trust you’re doing well!
Please make sure all plugins and WordPress core version is up to date. Usually, fatal errors can occur if there is a conflict with a plugin or something that went wrong during the plugin’s installation.
First please try to re-install the plugin and see if the issue still there
If the error will be back, please run a test for a conflict on your site.
– Deactivate all plugins, besides Smush, and see if all is well.
– If there is no error, please start activating one plugin at a time, till the issue will be back.
This way you will find what plugin is causing this issue.
Before running this test, please have a full backup of your site, so if something will go wrong you may always restore it back.
As @fierevere has suggested, please share with us the Fatal Errors that was emailed to you and the PHP version that is running on your site.
Kind regards,
Nastia