Comment box not appearing on posts when date is changed

The comment box on some posts is not appearing. It was showing until I past-dated the posts (or imported it from Squarespace). I tried changing the theme and disabling all plugins – the comment box still did not appear on past-dated posts. If there was already a comment that imported, it still shows. Any ideas on what could possibly be going on?

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]