• Resolved logicorulezz

    (@logicorulezz)


    I have a page called “Test Page” and a category called “Test Category”. I have redirected the “Test Category” to “Test Page” so that I can create an visually enhanced page for a category and also for a proper Silo website.

    When I create a new post under “Test Category”, the breadcrumb will be
    Home >> “Test Category” >> New Post

    but instead it should be (Desired Result)
    Home >> “Test Page” >> New Post as I have done a 301 redirection

    Please guide me in achieving this desired result

    • This topic was modified 4 years, 3 months ago by logicorulezz.
Viewing 4 replies - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Hey, just 2 days ago I wrote a detailed post to other users why you should not worry about “cornerstone content” and the same applies to “silo pages”. They are both just SEO jargon to make SEO sound complicated. There is no reason why PAGE can’t be your silo.

    Silo content was all the rage in 2016:
    Everything Should Not Be A Blog Post: Start Using Silos

    But by 2019, it is not even recommended:
    Stop the silo madness! Effective site architecture for SEO and findability

    The 2019 article presents a compelling argument about why you shouldn’t worry about “silos” and just periodically write quality content in a category you want to be perceived as a go-to resource.

    Of course, I do not know everything, so if you do think I’m wrong, I’m open to discussion and changing my mind.

    Thread Starter logicorulezz

    (@logicorulezz)

    Thanks @lebaux
    Went through the links shared. Its an eye opener.
    I believe I caused a confusion by mentioning about Silo.
    My primary objective was to use Page instead of Category Pages purely because Page can be optimized better.

    So I created a category for my posts and used 301 redirect from category page to the main page, which Im using a category Page and listing all blog posts.

    But the breadcrumbs don’t change automatically and is still showing the old category page instead of the new page.

    Plugin Author Sybre Waaijer

    (@cybr)

    Hello!

    The breadcrumbs don’t consider term redirects–it’s not part of the spec we applied. It won’t be easy to implement this feature, either.

    First, we’ll have to follow the redirect (because redirects can chain, and we must also hope that the chain is valid and doesn’t abort). Then, we’ll have to assess if the page it redirects to is part of your website, and is hierarchically related to the page displayed. Lastly, we’ll also have to find the right breadcrumb name.

    This link assertion alone can at least double the loading time of your page, only to satisfy a single line on Google.

    “But, I redirect to a page on the site.”–yes, that’s true. But not everyone will do that; this is an edge-case. Plus, you can supersede the redirect via other methods we cannot infer from the option, such as global Apache/.htaccess rules. I’m not one to bake in “only works some of the time” features into TSF.

    So, to work around this, we’ll have to allow you to manually insert breadcrumbs, which we oppose for various reasons.

    Ultimately, I believe this is a waste of time and effort; you’d be better off disabling the breadcrumb script and let Google try and figure out the hierarchy–they got a few million CPU hours spare that churn through redirects all day, without affecting your site’s performance ??

    Alternatively, you can use a structured data plugin alongside TSF that’ll allow you to fill in the breadcrumbs manually.

    Or–and I believe you should do this if you have the time and expertise–, keep using a real category without redirecting it, and use a (child-)theme template file to improve the output of the archive. This template will allow you to optimize it just as well as any other page.

    In any case, I hope this explains our stance on the issue and how we tackle things quite well. I also hope the alternatives are within reach ?? Cheers!

    Thread Starter logicorulezz

    (@logicorulezz)

    Hi, Thanks for taking time and giving such a detailed response. Understood the point. I will disable the breadcrumb and allow google to figure it out for now

    • This reply was modified 4 years, 3 months ago by logicorulezz.
Viewing 4 replies - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • The topic ‘changing category to page in breadcrumb’ is closed to new replies.