Can't renew Premium – verification code problems

I have been working on renewing my WordPress premium account all day and it all results in not being able to sign in with a verification code. I did have to download Authenticator again (new phone). I then tried the 2 step verification and that’s where it all started…

When clicking to renew in the email I received I am routed to my sign-in for my WordPress page. I have set this up to automatically fill with username and password. I can sign in, however, after signing in I go to enter the verification code and each time it tells me it’s invalid.

I may have set the Authenticator to an incorrect account, however, I would assume it should be my WordPress account name – silencingyournoise.wordpress.com

How can I set up a new verification code so I can renew my account. I’m getting nervous because my account expires today. Yikes