Can’t enable Security Check

Going through the initial setup on two sites on the same host. One had no issues enabling Security Check, but on the other site it’s not enabling. Even when clicking on the notifications on the top bar and trying to enable Security Check the button animates like it’s trying, but does nothing.

On the second step of the setup under IP Detection the drop down doesn’t even have a selection for Security Check Scan.

I’ve tried deactivating and reactivating and uninstalling and reinstalling and the issue persists. The Plugins are the exact same on both sites and both are the current version of WP.

Help…