Cannot display all past events

I have a short code set up for past events. I am using just list view and a limit of ‘8’ with the load more button enabled. ‘Show Only Expired Events’ is set to true but it will only show one of the events, the ‘latest’ past event.

I added older events that you can find if you change the year in the filter they show up but it seems like the display strangely. If you filter it to April 2005, for example, it will show July 2004 and April 2003. If I change it to August 2005 it will only show July 2004. But if I change it go December 2005 it will show July 2004 and my August 2005 events. Also strange that it doesn’t show my August 2005 events when the filter is get to August 2005?

I updated everything to the latest versions, and I disabled all my other plugins and it only displays the one event without filtering. I am guessing it is set to only show events back a certain amount of time. Can this be adjusted?

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]