Buttons duplicated under posts

Can you please check your ShareThis Plugin Settings Page – Step-4
Where you have option to show the buttons on Top or below the post.
Please make sure that you have unchecked the option to show the buttons on Top of the Page.
Screenshot – https://screencast.com/t/kI2AaYopJw

Thanks for the response!

Here is my settings screen:
https://www.screencast.com/t/auHYwqUSeZ4q

I think it looks like yours.

Here is what it looks like with the plugin deactivated:
https://www.screencast.com/t/REi9ZHaYo

It seems you have deactivated the ShareThis Plugin.
But in your website code, we can see that ShareThis SPAN tag code is still present. Which seems to be implemented manually apart from Plugin installation.

<span st_url='https://www.michaelpink.com/goals-trading-life/' st_title='What Goals Are You Trading Your Life For?' class='st_facebook_hcount'></span>
<span st_via='@MichaelPink' st_username='MichaelPink' st_url='https://www.michaelpink.com/goals-trading-life/' st_title='What Goals Are You Trading Your Life For?' class='st_twitter_hcount'></span>
<span st_url='https://www.michaelpink.com/goals-trading-life/' st_title='What Goals Are You Trading Your Life For?' class='st_googleplus_hcount'></span>
<span st_url='https://www.michaelpink.com/goals-trading-life/' st_title='What Goals Are You Trading Your Life For?' class='st_linkedin_hcount'></span>
<span st_url='https://www.michaelpink.com/goals-trading-life/' st_title='What Goals Are You Trading Your Life For?' class='st_sharethis_hcount'></span>
<span st_url='https://www.michaelpink.com/goals-trading-life/' st_title='What Goals Are You Trading Your Life For?' class='st_email_hcount'></span>

If the Plugin is deactivated, then this code should not be present in your site code.
So this can be a reason behind duplicate buttons. Please remove the above code and activate the Plugin and check again.

If you still face the same issue, then we suggest you to deactivate all other installed Plugins and check again.

Our site got hacked, so all the plugins stopped working. We are in the process of doing a site restore.

This, I think, does explain the problem, though. I think the original webmasters added some code to the theme. I’ll try turning off the ‘show buttons on bottoms of posts’ and see if it looks right then.

Turns out, that was exactly the problem. I turned off the bottom of post buttons and it works like a champ now.

Thank you for your attention. Sorry it was our problem!