Animate it is missing from the right menu

Is the plugin broken now?

Hello a4jp,

My apologies for the delayed reply due to a holiday week here in Central India.
The Dev team just did a test of the plugin using the latest WordPress version, and the icons is appearing fine on all the areas.

You can check the screenshots here:
Classic Editor: https://shared-assets.adobe.com/link/3215f841-c906-49e2-6d37-289c9dae284a
Gutenberg Editor: https://shared-assets.adobe.com/link/2966b500-66c9-4f8f-44da-bf9ff1e26690
Block Editor: https://shared-assets.adobe.com/link/03858095-7935-4a2a-45ce-3cf1ad1517f6

My suggestion would be to turn off all plugins and activate them one by one to see which plugin is causing a conflict.