• ResolvedPlugin Contributor meglio

    (@meglio)


    Ibid is a widely-used notation that means “same as previous”.

    Example footnote 1:

    Life in Australia – Australian Values and Principles, Commonwealth of Australia, 2016, 7.

    Example footnote 2:

    Ibid 8.

    In footnote 2, it says “same as footnote 1, but the page number is 8.

    “Ibid” is a legal standard.

Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Plugin Contributor pewgeuges

    (@pewgeuges)

    @meglio

    That is very good practice! Adding the changing page number adds value to the footnote and helps the reader look up the precise citations.

    Ibid works well when the source remains the same, as in the case you quote, also when sources are used sequentially. Some web pages may however mix the sources by using several sources in parallel. Then the solution is to use academic shorthand. In a variation on your example:

    Example footnote 1:

    Life in Australia – Australian Values and Principles, Commonwealth of Australia, 2020, 7 [Life?2020].

    Example footnote 2:

    Australian Mosaic – Exploring Australian Values, The magazine of the Federation of Ethnic Communities’ Councils of Australia (FECCA), issue?51, June?2019, 34 [Mosaic?51].

    Example footnote 3:

    Life?2020, 8.

    Example footnote 4:

    Mosaic?51, 23.

    ???

    Whether we use Ibid or another citation shorthand highly depends on how the subject is discussed. In the above thematic approach, the author would iterate through the sources, citing them repeatedly one after the other. By contrast, Ibid is used when the author first exploits one source, and once done, moves on to the next source. That is what you are showcasing:

    Example footnote 1:

    Life in Australia – Australian Values and Principles, Commonwealth of Australia, 2020, 7.

    Example footnote 2:

    Ibid. 8.

    Example footnote 3:

    Australian Mosaic – Exploring Australian Values, The magazine of the Federation of Ethnic Communities’ Councils of Australia (FECCA), Issue?51, June?2019, 34.

    Example footnote 4:

    Ibid. 23.

    ???

    So in fact, we’re already holding the solution. Best practice is to make each footnote unique by adding useful details like you are doing by being specific about page numbers.

    Please let us know which feature you have in mind to add support for in Footnotes?

    Best regards.

    Plugin Contributor pewgeuges

    (@pewgeuges)

    @meglio

    Just got it! Thank you very much for your request. It will improve the dashboard. It’s for the description in the “Footnotes numbering” settings container under General settings. It traces the way to provide better guidance and emboldens us to go ahead.

    I’ll try to post the new text here in preview of upcoming v2.2.5.

    Thank you for helping improve the plugin and write better footnotes!

    Plugin Contributor pewgeuges

    (@pewgeuges)

    For review: The following guidance is set up for addition to v2.2.5 in the dashboard > General settings > Footnotes numbering:

    Even when footnotes are combined, footnote numbers keep incrementing. This avoids suboptimal referrer and backlink disambiguation using a secondary numbering system. The Ibid. notation followed by the current page number avoids repeating the footnote content. For changing sources, shortened citations may be used. Repeating full citations is also an opportunity to add details.

    Credit is added in the changelog and in header and comments in class/dashboard/subpage-main.php.

    Many thanks again!

Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • The topic ‘Add support for Ibid notation’ is closed to new replies.