404 error. Possibly related to permalink

I am working on this site: https://www.artisaninsurance.com/
I want the contact page to be SSL It was “https://artisaninsurance.com/contact-us/”

This is shared SSL so I set it up as https://secure.jhstudios.net/~artisa/

When I have it enabled and click the nav button, It takes me to this URL https://secure.jhstudios.net/~artisa/contact-us/

This looks right, but instead of displaying the contact us page, it displays a 404 message from my apache server. If I remove the “/contact_us” to make sure I have the server and username correct, it displays the site as well as would be expected since it is not properly invoking the plugin.

I’ll have to uncheck Force SSL until I get an answer so that my customer’s page isn’t broken.