all posts have the same comments.. HELP

I have this same issue, and cannot locate the source. I was using a comment callback in order to customize the appearance of comments. (listed pings and comment separate) I was sure this was the issue, but when I uploaded the ‘default’ comment.php and reverted my customization, the error still persists.

My template is 100% from scratch, custom work for a client. I have a feeling this may be caused by a plugin … if I discover anything I will post back here.

Weird. An echo of $post->ID before the_content() yields expected results, but if I echo $post->ID after the_content(), it gives me the ‘phantom’ ID of a particular post on every page, ID=468. This is the ID that the comments are using, and why all comments posted are posted to this page.

My first suspect is get_posts and/or query_posts corrupting the loop, but there are no get_posts/query_posts on within this template, or ran at all before the loop.

Is it possible that there’s some problems with the_content()? Anybody have a solution, or any ideas what may be causing this?

I was using Custom Widgets Plugin, Disabling this plugin worked for me, but it is likely that it wasn’t the plugin, probably the custom widgets that I did create.

na3s was right when says something its corrumping the loop, there are two ways to fixit
the problem occurs when any another query_post from any reason is useit before comments_template()

if (have_posts()) : while (have_posts()) : the_post();
$temporal = $post->ID;
…..
another query_post from any reason
…..
$post->ID = $temporal;
comments_template();

so with a temporal fix that issue, the other way its to use a instance for the query $my_query = new WP_Query().

victoredier: thank you, merci, gracias, choukran, obrigado ouffff spent hours and hours seraching for this: https://www.el-guanabanero.org small village citizen newspaper has now comments working!!!