Hi Jan,
This is true that I came across point theme through the promotional offer, having said that I downloaded the theme point and tried it on one of my websites and found it as it is written in the review here, the theme is good one with a nice panel options and stuff.
For the part of honesty in this promotion, i certainly agree with you that just for an offer you must not give a fancy review to a theme but, if someone tries a theme and gives his/her views over it. I don’t think there is a problem.
I have been in touch with mythemeshop for sometime now and I have seen them doing good work. And as a result I tried to support them.
If it is not ethically correct which I agree may be not , we must report such practices to the wordpress admins. I am with you for that .