First, let me say, this is your toy and you can do whatever you want! ??
I agree that when thinking of it as an “order,” 1-10 makes sense. But, since it’s labeled “weight” and the user is already used to thinking of the heavier weight being more important, then intuitively, switching from random to ordered, the higher weight, the more important, the higher in the list it should be.
Plus, when switching from random to ordered, instead of one click of a radio button, the user also has to reverse the weight of every ad in the group. Not that big of a deal for up to 10 ads, but still, a click is a click! ??
All in all, I’m not gonna be disappointed either way. I think this is a great plugin. Simple, straight-forward, with more features being added and tweaked all the time. AND you’re very active in the support threads and you even implement the ideas of your users…quickly!
Kudos to you, my friend! ??