New subscribers not showing up in stats

Hello,

I was hoping someone can help with my issue. I was wondering why when i keep getting new emails saying I have new people following my blog my blog count on my stats page do not go up? I understand someone can follow and unfollow but it seems like i have received too many emails without my follower count increasing. I have noticed this issue started when i moved my blog to self hosted. I use JetPack. I added a new plugin to show a widget with the latest people to register and it is showing all of the new users even though it doesn’t show up under the Jetpack stats. It does seem like a Jetpack glitch. Is there another plugin that will show subscriber count in stats?

Please let me know if there are any questions and I appreciate any help!!

My blog is https://searchingforthehappiness.com