Two Identical Pages

I see you’re using the Diner theme from woothemes. They do have free support for their premium themes. I don’t know the exact codes they used to generate the menu, but check your theme’s header.php where it might be that they hardcoded the home link which you can delete or comment out. Then just use Page Order (right sidebar of Page Add New or Page Edit panel) on all the pages so that the Home Page will be first in list of menu items.

I have not received and response from Woothemes all day.
I’m not good with code so I hoping you could take a look at my header.php code and see if you see the hard code and where to delete it.

Here is the link to my pastebin

https://pastebin.com/0U0n2p5p

Now I hit, TRASH on the Home page, and the menu says Home but a page error occurs

WooThemes Support: https://www.woothemes.com/support/

Try dashboard menu > Appearance > Menus – choose Primary Menu and create your main navigation there and save. See if that works.

If not there, there might be some navigation settings available in Appearance > Theme Options page. So many things are going on in that theme so can’t really give you the definitive guide. Only the woothemes devs can.