How to have 1 post point to 2 difrent single.php files

How to have 1 post point to 2 difrent single.php files. I have created theme that use 2 Facebook like box, they are on 1 post, now, I wish to ask is it possible to, when somebody click and like on first like box to have lets say domain.com/post-1 and when somebody click on second like box to have domain.com/post-2 … I have crated 2 single.php themes but I do not know how to put together all this … I am willing to pay somebody for this.

Thank you