Only works with one restriction

Sorry for the newb question — I’m trying to build multiple restrictions:

1. Subscribers > able to see a specific page after log in
2. Contributors > able to see 2 specific pages (including page from #1) after log in

WHAT I’VE DONE
I tried created one restriction for all logged in users: selected page (first page), which will be seen by all users.
I created another restriction for the Contributors/Admin: selected page (second page), which can only be accessed by contributors or admin.

I’ve moved the two around, added the selected page to the contributors/admin, but it doesn’t process, just displays the restricted message to even the contributors.

Any help would be great!