Recipe Bottom Navigation

There seems to be an issue with the pagination at the bottom of the Recipes archive page, and it shows error when you try to go to the second page.

Because I will take the website live, I will show for now all recipes in one page, but please check the issue

The templates developers told me this:
when “Settings > Permalinks” set to “Plain” and it disappears when “Permalinks” set to “Post name”. I have switched to the default theme and same issue there, which proves that this is a bug related to Cooked plugin not the theme.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]