I agree. imposing a new naming schema on everyone, by default, and without even a setting to NOT use such an opinionated naming change is horrible. Also, I often have long path names, and this adds a lot of unwanted, unexpected characters. Mostly, though, I dislike the way it pollutes all filenames. And it is quite a break from decades of past image uploads. I do not mind that they are resized by default (although for a past website I might). I really dislike the naming. And that’s a lot more typing when I manually add images to my pages (it’s really the only way to get my design right).
When changing such a long-standing convention, keep the default setting unchanged, and allow the new “way” to be enabled by a switch in the backend settings admin panel.
I’m in the middle of a major re haul of my media library. Renaming images, re-uploading, and setting new sizes. Re-organizing, thinning. And I need to manually update links to all images. Now with your new naming schema, I will have to redo what I’d already done, else my dev and live versions of uploads will not match.
For every reason imaginable, but largely because it is ugly, and breaks consistency, I hate it.
Media Library needs a MAJOR Redo. We cannot organize our images how we like, into folders, and it is too difficult to clean up our libraries.
Adding “scaled” to names is an change was unnecessary!!
A decade on and plugins attempt to address the very real need users have, but no one can stay long term, or fully address the huge mess created by the legacy library.
It made sense initially to organized images by year/month,. But WordPress is hardly limited to blog posts.
We cannot group related images in folders.
Or easily rename images – the actual url links, or clean out the library, or replace existing images with new ones. Or find unneeded, unused, or duplicate images easily.
OR IMPORT images to the library if we upload them directly to the server!!
These are some features we *do* need.