Different sorting on different pages

Sorry the free plugin can’t do that, you might want to check with advanced, though which you can create multiple sorts and apply those to different areas, see the following:

1. How to create a sort list https://www.nsp-code.com/advanced-post-types-order-description-and-usage/create-simple-sort-for-a-custom-post-type/
2. How to apply a conditional to apply a sort on specific area https://www.nsp-code.com/advanced-post-types-order-description-and-usage/using-conditionals-for-sorting-apply/

Thanks